Mavic Comète Ultimate II in review – Successor to the € 1,000 shoe released

With the new Comète Ultimate II, Mavic present the second version of their exclusive race-performance oriented shoe. Have the weaknesses of the original been ironed out and is the costly upgrade to the second generation worth it? We’ve been testing the shoes for the last two months to find out.

With the new, updated Comète Ultimate II, Mavic show just how much technology fits into a shoe. We tested the original version back in 2017 in our exclusive test. The two-piece carbon shell and inner shoe are all about achieving record values for power transfer and are designed to make you feel completely at one with your bike. Carbon is used in the weave of the inner shoe for increased stability, while the weight (210 g per shoe in size 42.5) has also been reduced. The Comète Ultimate II is also designed to feel more precise and comfortable on the foot. To do this, the range of sizes has been doubled from 6 to 12 options (40 to 47 ⅓) and the padding has been redeveloped. The minimal stack height of 4.5 mm has remained the same, just like the low volume toe box. Likewise, the Mavic Ergo fasteners have also been inherited from the original model. Alongside the weight, the price has also fallen. That said, the Comète Ultimate II still costs € 700.

Mavic Comète Ultimate II on test

The initial impression of the Comète Ultimate II is of a graceful and premium shoe. The finishing is of the highest quality and the two piece construction looks like it’s hewn from one block. Of course, the fit of a shoe depends on the individual and will be subjective for everyone. However, compared to its predecessor, we can say that wider feet will also feel at home in the Comète Ultimate II, with the last no longer cut quite so narrow. The more flexible rand on the inside also boosts comfort noticeably. It’s only particularly flat feet that might still experience pressure points, for which the Mavic Ergo dials will have to be left far open. However, ‘average feet’ shouldn’t have any problems fitting. Compared to the flexible inner shoe, the exoskeleton is extremely stiff and doesn’t budge an inch. Bear that in mind as if the shoe has a pressure point when you first put it on, then that pressure point is likely there to stay. As mentioned, fit is subjective and you should definitely try the shoe on in person.

The stack height of 4.5 mm is very small and results in direct power transfer. That, combined with the high stiffness that clearly defines the Comète Ultimate II as a race-performance shoe that just wants to get out and sprint. For relaxed Sunday afternoon rides there are less sporty models out there with more stretch and less stiff soles. The carbon outer shell means accidental contact with tyres isn’t a problem. Unlike other shoes, there’s nothing to mark or discolour here. The ventilation is adequate, but might meet its limits on very hot days.

Conclusion

The new Mavic Comète Ultimate II is the logical development of its predecessor, perfect for all Mavic fans and performance-oriented riders. The low weight paired with the extra stiff exoskeleton and low stack height result in a dedicated, performance-focused product. Thanks to 12 different sizes, more flexible sides and a wider last, those with slightly wider feet will also be able to appreciate the Comète Ultimate II, as long as you have the spare change.

---

Did you enjoy this article? If so, we would be stoked if you decide to support us with a monthly contribution. By becoming a supporter of GRAN FONDO, you will help secure a sustainable future for high-quality cycling journalism. Click here to learn more.

Words & Photos: Philipp Schwab